The idea of weaving exposition into the narrative, and then weaving the narrative into the gameplay itself, is a kind of holy grail for developers—and it’s one I believe The Witness achieves, even as it manages the additional impressive feat of creating a compelling conversation between science and religion.
Jonathan Blow’s The Witness has me intrigued. A Myst game for the modern era.
I tend to forget how hard Myst was. Sure, the game was beautiful in it’s time. But Myst required coordination with other players. Writing down clues, puzzles,and code. The ultimate water cooler game.
Polygon — 8/10
“But The Witness throws endless puzzles at the player while almost never recognizing their accomplishments, which creates something of an antagonistic relationship between player and creator. I fear that will send players running to walkthroughs faster than they would have in a more rewarding environment.” — Justin McElroy [Review]
USgamer — 2/5
“And that’s the overlying problem: The Witness doesn’t care if you’re having fun—for the most part, it relishes in how clever it can be. There’s some joy to discovery, sure, but once that’s over with, you’re just scraping against the few things in your way. I appreciate Blow’s lack of presence in his world, but it’s a blessing as much as a curse. Of course, I understand what he’s doing: The Witness is very much a modern-day update of Myst, and meant to be played as if we were back in 1993. Ultimately, it feels like something designed to be chipped away at over weeks or months—not an experience to cruise through over a handful of afternoons.” — Bob Mackey [Review]
I have read several reviews that liken The Witness to Dark Souls or even the more recent Bloodborne. Games that demand skill, patience, and an almost sharing of secrets. My more recent foray into Bloodborne had me consulting with friends for both strategy and encouragement.
The modern era has us all on our individual technological islands. What if certain types of games force us off of them? Forcing us to bridge the virtual gap, to talk in person, to somehow experience humanity again. Yes, that sounds dramatic. But you understand where I am going. Gaming has become a much more isolated experience, despite the internet. I am all for games that force us to connect with one another. Even if that connection is forged over progress and survival.
Are you playing The Witness? Tell me about your experience in the comments below.
Nintendo Entertainment System (NES)
- BattleToads – Just noticed that Falco, from the StarFox series, is in the intro video. His first job perhaps? 🙂
- Kings of the Beach
- Mario Brothers
- Ninja Turtles Arcade
- Ninja Turtles: The Manhattan Project
- Desert Strike
- Golden Axe
- NBA Jam
- Road Rash
- Sonic the Hedgehog
- Spiderman: Separation Anxiety
- Banjo Kazooie
- Bio F.R.E.A.K.S.
- Diddy Kong Racing
- Duke Nukem 64
- Mark Kart 64
- San Francisco: Rush
- Super Smash Brothers
- Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
- Command and Conquer / Red Alert
- Diablo 1 & 2
- Homeworld/ Cataclysm
- Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis
- Mechwarrior 2
- Monkey Island Series
- Sam and Max
- Starcraft/ Warcraft/ Warcraft II
- World of Warcraft
- Garou: Mark of the Wolves
- Golden Axe
- Metal Slug
- Time Crisis II
Any games you miss playing with your friends? Add to the list in the comments below!